HCOMP 2024 Review Criteria


Full papers submitted to HCOMP 2024 will be evaluated according to the following review criteria. Our intent in posting review criteria online is to further improve transparency of the conference's peer-review process and to provide additional guidance to authors in preparing their submissions (especially for young researchers, as well as researchers from diverse disciplines).

Feedback or suggestions for further improving these review criteria? Tweet us @hcomp_conf or email us at hcomp24@easychair.org.


Presentation and Writing

Citations and Prior Work


Significance and Impact

Data, Code, and Resources

Soundness & Validity


Camera-ready Acknowledgments – Thank your Crowd!

When writing acknowledgments in the final, camera-ready versions of accepted papers, we encourage authors to thank their crowd contributors. After all, we couldn't conduct our research or run our crowd-powered systems without the many individual contributors who choose to participate!


We welcome everyone who is interested in crowdsourcing and human computation to:

  • Join crowd-hcomp Google Group (mailing list) to post and receive crowdsourcing and human computation email announcements (e.g., calls-for-papers, job openings, etc.) including updates here about the conference. To subscribe send an email to crowd-hcomp+subscribe@googlegroups.com.
  • Check our Google Group webpage to view the archive of past communications on the HCOMP mailing list.
  • Keep track of our twitter hashtag #HCOMP2024.
  • Join the HCOMP Slack Community to be in touch with researchers, industry players, practitioners, and crowd workers around Human Computation and relevant topics.